Candy

We have a large assortment of items to satisfy your sweet tooth.  We carry several hard to find candies and some that are just extra fun!
137 products
Sanded Rootbeer Drops
Sanded Rootbeer Drops
Old World Amish
$3.09
Sanded Raspberry Drops
Sanded Raspberry Drops
Old World Amish
$3.09
Sanded Lemon Drops
Sanded Lemon Drops
Old World Amish
$3.09
Sanded Horehound Drops
Sanded Horehound Drops
Old World Amish
$3.09
Salted Caramels
Salted Caramels
Old World Amish
$3.99
Red Raspberry Twists
Red Raspberry Twists
Old World Amish
$2.49
Red Juju Coins
Red Juju Coins
Old World Amish
$2.79
Peanut M&Ms
Peanut M&Ms
Old World Amish
$8.05
Peanut Butter Monkey Munch
Peanut Butter Monkey Munch
Old World Amish
$10.74
Party Mints
Party Mints
Old World Amish
$4.09
Ornery Orange Gummi Bears
Ornery Orange Gummi Bears
Old World Amish
$3.49
Orange Slices
Orange Slices
Old World Amish
$1.99
Neopolitan Twist Pretzels
Neopolitan Twist Pretzels
Old World Amish
$11.47
Mint Puffs
Mint Puffs
Old World Amish
$1.99
Yogurt Mini Pretzels
Yogurt Mini Pretzels
Old World Amish
$4.59
Mini Toffee Pretzels
Mini Toffee Pretzels
Old World Amish
$11.25
Mini Sea Salt Caramels
Mini Sea Salt Caramels
Old World Amish
$4.89
Mini Reeses Pieces
Mini Reeses Pieces
Old World Amish
$5.89
Mini Peanut Butter Cups
Mini Peanut Butter Cups
Old World Amish
$4.69
Mini Orange Slices
Mini Orange Slices
Old World Amish
$2.39