WE ARE CURRENTLY EXPERIENCING SUPPLY SHORTAGES OF HAPPY SALT. ORDERS PLACED ALREADY, WILL BE FULFILLED WHEN PRODUCT IS BACK IN STOCK. NO NEW HAPPY SALT ORDERS ARE BEING ACCEPTED TEMPORARILY. WE EXPECT TO HAVE HAPPY SALT BACK BY JUNE 1ST. WE APOLOGIZE FOR ANY INCONVENIENCE. - OLD WORLD AMISH

Candy

We have a large assortment of items to satisfy your sweet tooth.  We carry several hard to find candies and some that are just extra fun!
149 products
Chocolate Malt Balls
Chocolate Malt Balls
Grabill Country Sales
$6.49
White Straw Banana Bears
White Straw Banana Bears
Old World Amish
$3.39
Tootsie Rolls - Assorted Flavors
Tootsie Rolls - Assorted Flavors
Old World Amish
$3.79
Swirly Gummi Fish
Swirly Gummi Fish
Old World Amish
$4.59
Strawberry Yogurt Pretzels
Strawberry Yogurt Pretzels
Old World Amish
$5.99
Strawberry Wheels
Strawberry Wheels
Old World Amish
$3.69
Strawberry Bon-Bons
Strawberry Bon-Bons
Old World Amish
$2.39
Strawberry and Blueberries
Strawberry and Blueberries
Old World Amish
$9.60
Spiced Chocolate Cranberry Almonds
Spiced Chocolate Cranberry Almonds
Old World Amish
$8.49
Spice Drops
Spice Drops
Old World Amish
$2.49
Speckled Chocolate Almonds
Speckled Chocolate Almonds
Old World Amish
$6.49
Spearmint Starlites
Spearmint Starlites
Old World Amish
$2.79
Spearmint Leaves
Spearmint Leaves
Old World Amish
$2.49
Sour Watermelon Slices
Sour Watermelon Slices
Old World Amish
$3.69
Sour Slices
Sour Slices
Old World Amish
$2.49