Candy

We have a large assortment of items to satisfy your sweet tooth.  We carry several hard to find candies and some that are just extra fun!
170 products
12 Flavor Gummi Bears
12 Flavor Gummi Bears
Old World Amish
$4.49
6 Flavor Gummi Bears
6 Flavor Gummi Bears
Old World Amish
$2.99
Anise Bears
Anise Bears
Old World Amish
$1.99
Anise Squares
Anise Squares
Old World Amish
$2.39
Apple Rings
Apple Rings
Old World Amish
$2.59
Assorted Blow Pops
Assorted Blow Pops
Old World Amish
$7.49
Assorted Chiclet Gum
Assorted Chiclet Gum
Old World Amish
$4.39
Assorted Dehydrated Marshmallow Bits
Assorted Dehydrated Marshmallow Bits
Old World Amish
$8.18
Assorted Flavored Runts
Assorted Flavored Runts
Old World Amish
$3.99
Assorted Fruit Slices
Assorted Fruit Slices
Old World Amish
$4.65
Assorted Fruit Twists
Assorted Fruit Twists
Old World Amish
$3.99
Assorted Giant Gumdrops
Assorted Giant Gumdrops
Old World Amish
$2.39
Assorted Gum Balls
Assorted Gum Balls
Old World Amish
$4.29
Assorted Honey Filled Candy
Assorted Honey Filled Candy
Old World Amish
$3.04
Assorted Jolly Rancher Candy
Assorted Jolly Rancher Candy
Old World Amish
$5.50
Assorted Jordan Almonds
Assorted Jordan Almonds
Old World Amish
$7.49
Assorted Salt Water Taffy
Assorted Salt Water Taffy
Old World Amish
$2.29
Banarama Candy Bananas
Banarama Candy Bananas
Old World Amish
$4.49
Baseball Gum
Baseball Gum
Old World Amish
$1.99
Bit-O-Honey
Bit-O-Honey
Old World Amish
$3.29
Black Jack Taffy
Black Jack Taffy
Old World Amish
$2.39
Black Licorice Bites
Black Licorice Bites
Old World Amish
$3.79
Blue Raspberry Frooties
Blue Raspberry Frooties
Old World Amish
$1.99
Blue Raspberry Twists
Blue Raspberry Twists
Old World Amish
$1.99
Blueberry Yogurt Pretzels
Blueberry Yogurt Pretzels
Old World Amish
$4.29